To the Editor:
It is clear that the decision to have Kofi Annan speak at this year's Commencement has been met with both criticism and applause. Both reactions are not only understandable, but they are healthy in an open society. Penn is no lame duck when it comes to being a brewing ground for tomorrow's politicians, so a passionate dialogue is completely expected in the wake of such an announcement.
As a senior at Penn, I am looking forward to graduating. My family is looking forward to the event, as are 2,500 other families. At the event, there will be Republican families, Democratic families and even mixed families. Some will listen attentively to what Mr. Annan will say; others will wait impatiently so that they can leave the outdoor heat and retire to a more pleasant location.
Regardless of which variety of family, I am sure none would like to see the Commencement ceremony of their son or daughter turn into a political protest with people holding up half-witted signs about Mr. Annan's scandals, the alleged incompetence of the U.N. or even allegations of its anti-democracy or anti-Israel policies.
I am not arguing that all of these accusations are false, nor am I an ardent supporter of Mr. Annan. The College Republicans, Pro-Israel Coalition and others have every right to sign petitions and make an effort to change the speaker.
However, if their requests are not acknowledged, they have no right to spoil the importance and tradition of Commencement. It is a day held in high esteem by many, and to deface it with a protest would be disrespectful to the graduating seniors and their families. Unfortunately, there is only one Commencement for all of us, so everyone will not be pleased with the speaker.
I say make the efforts now, sign the petitions now; otherwise forever hold your peace.
Amar Bansal
Engineering '05
